
“Pony Up,” the debut album by indie pop duo Pen Pin, is so bright that it can bring an almost instant smile to your face within the first few seconds of music. It is a strangely satisfying grin that stays there even after the twelfth track ends and silence returns.
The project features Jeni Magaña and Emily Moore, two songwriters and multi-instrumentalists who met while touring with Mitski and quickly became friends. For their debut, the two played nearly every instrument and co-produced a dozen songs filled with sweetness, reflections tucked into intentional verbal quirks, and personal stories that accompanied the making of “Pony Up.”
An acoustic guitar on the verge of saturation welcomes listeners to the album with “Dishes.” The song hints at what’s to come from its very first verse, as Magaña and Moore’s voices come together until they almost sound like one.
“Fade Out” follows right away, sealing the deal for anyone who might have resisted the opening track. In the video, the two share the screen in a house that looks like it was pulled straight out of 1970s and 1980s America. The 4:3 aspect ratio and VHS texture accentuate the period feel of the shiny tiles, dark wood furniture, floral tablecloths, and crystal dinnerware.
Dressed in lace, the two bake a cake and pick up the leftover birthday confetti, sharing a sense of closeness that extends all the way into the garden. The colors are as saturated as some of the album’s instruments. On the table, a music notebook and strings of white lights sit alongside a chocolate cake, plates, and candles. It’s a party for two that doesn’t need anyone else.
That same ease in having fun together can also be heard in “Holiday,” “Postcards,” and “Fringe,” where layers of vocals and instruments bring back the warmth of seventies pop. Pen Pin call the inspiration they found in their friendship and shared love of pop from past decades “pen pinspiration.” In “Fringe,” that affinity comes through in how comfortably their voices move together among the instruments.
“Star Crazy” introduces a little more drama, while “Vampire” brings back the freshness with an arrangement in which each vocal and instrumental layer gives the song a different dimension. “Maria,” meanwhile, has a more organic sound. The strings take center stage, while a more understated acoustic guitar supports the arrangement and leaves room for both voices to stand out.

Subtle flashes of funk and disco slip into “The Boredom,” “Spooky Love,” and “Patience,” adding new colors without disrupting the intimacy. “Heat Shimmer” dims the lights with an enveloping closing track. When silence returns, a little of the intimacy from the party in “Fade Out” lingers, as if the listener had also been given a seat at the table throughout those twelve songs.

